Send me a FREE trial issue Plus a FREE gift
Old-House Online » Old-House Tips, Restoration Stories, & More » Repairs & How To » An Energy-Efficient Tudor Retrofit

An Energy-Efficient Tudor Retrofit

A forward-thinking team converts a derelict Tudor in Geneva, Illinois, into a model of energy efficiency.
By Frank Elder | Photos by Brian DeWolf

    This Tudor house in Geneva, Illinois, went from downtrodden to desirable, thanks to an energy-efficient retrofit that was mindful of the house’s history.

    This Tudor house in Geneva, Illinois, went from downtrodden to desirable, thanks to an energy-efficient retrofit that was mindful of the house’s history.

    Ernie Mahaffey is not a house flipper. He bought the vacant house up the block from his own home of 20 years in Geneva, Illinois, because he “could see the vultures swooping in.” The under-loved 1929 brick Tudor home with a rampantly overgrown landscape—newly vacant in the height of the housing boom—provoked in him a familiar desire: to rehabilitate a fixer-upper threatened with destruction.

    The place was a wreck, according to a seven-item summary of “major structural defects” Ernie’s building engineer cataloged. Unfazed by the prognosis, Ernie decided he would go beyond the structural repairs to upgrade the house to the strictest efficiency standards in the world: the Passivhaus.

    Developed in Germany, Passivhaus standards call for an extreme reduction in a building’s carbon footprint. Through stringent requirements on insulation, infiltration, and heat retention, the standards result in a building that needs almost no input from an HVAC system to regulate indoor climate. Hitting these standards—or even coming close—would have major implications. The home could act as a case study to show how radical new building techniques could preserve existing structures while cutting their consumption to near zero. Ernie envisioned a historic homeowner’s dream: a subtle blend of state-of-the-art new systems in a building that retained all the charm and character of decades past. To pull it off, his architect, Tom Bassett-Dilley of the Oak Park, Illinois, firm Drawing On Place, would use the house as a laboratory to challenge the conventional wisdom of restoration.

    Energy Matters

    The time-worn front door, a distinctive detail, was completely rehabilitated.

    The time-worn front door, a distinctive detail, was completely rehabilitated.

    Under the close scrutiny of the Geneva Historic Preservation Board, Tom knew that adding conspicuous new materials to the exterior of the house was out of the question. But his desire to bring the house to cutting-edge 21st-century standards didn’t exactly provoke a clash with the board.

    “Historic preservation is energy efficient,” says Karla Kaulfuss, Geneva’s historic preservation planner. “And true energy efficiency is about looking at the whole project, then evaluating each building for its own issues and its own capabilities.” Preservation is a balancing act, she says, requiring an open-minded approach from both the board and the owners to achieve what is ultimately a shared objective.

    For instance, the house gains much of its character from a stunning series of divided-light windows, an oriel on the front façade, and a 12′-tall picture window in the vaulted-ceiling great room. The Preservation Board insisted the original windows stay, so Tom upped their efficiency by rehabilitating the original sash. Then he finessed a cost-effective standby: Original wood storms were reglazed with single-pane glass with a low-E coating. For the few storms too worn to recondition, the team made new storms to match out of white pine. For maximum seal, storm windows also were installed with peel-away caulking along their interior edges. “It’s just good building science,” says Tom. “It’s about how you take care of the envelope, and you can do that for not a lot of money.”

    Two varieties of high-tech insulation were installed in the house—white open-cell foam in attic rafters and dense-pack gray cellulose on the walls.

    Two varieties of high-tech insulation were installed in the house—white open-cell foam in attic rafters and dense-pack gray cellulose on the walls.

    A solid building envelope—basically, an unbroken exterior barrier that maintains a static indoor temperature—is central to the Passivhaus philosophy and to Tom’s plan. “The house had zero insulation,” says Tad Hemming of Hemming Construction, the project’s general contractor. Tad and Tom mapped out a strategy that would eliminate every “thermal bridge”—a spot that allows heat to pass through the house walls.

    The team added dense-packed cellulose to every wall stud bay and installed 7″ of air-impermeable open-cell foam in attic rafters. Because heat migrates through the studs on exterior walls, Tad ran ½” furring strips perpendicular to the studs on their interior face, allowing an extra layer of insulation to envelop the framing members so they don’t make direct contact with the finished wall surfaces.

    “They just insulated like crazy,” says Tony Botkin, an energy auditor from Intelligent Energy Solutions, a nearby firm hired to measure the house’s efficiency. Tony describes the dense-pack cellulose technique as a cascade of fibrous wood pulp passing through a stream of water before entering the stud bays. “It’s almost like blowing a spitball into the wall,” he says. “You just fill it until you can’t fit any more.” As Tom puts it: “We took a house that was really leaky and drafty, then with good insulation, good storm windows, efficient lighting, and the right-sized furnaces, built a house that’s way better than the current energy code—and this is for 1929 construction.”

    Maintaining History

    With the big-picture energy issues solved, Tom could focus on the historic details essential to the restoration. To rebuild a collapsing exterior wall, Steve Patzer, a talented local mason, hand-numbered individual bricks as he took them down so he could reassemble them in exactly the same position using a skintled brick technique. Tad’s crew re-created knockdown plaster walls in the front parlor rooms by spraying drywall mud through a wide-broadcast nozzle, then using 2′ knives to smooth the resulting cake-icing stipple into a coarse surface.

    Before work began, the kitchen was in such bad shape that no appliances remained. The finished room retains an arched entryway and radius window, while adding new cabinets and countertops.

    Before work began, the kitchen was in such bad shape that no appliances remained. The finished room retains an arched entryway and radius window, while adding new cabinets and countertops.

    In the front parlor, Tad removed the exposed beams from the vaulted ceiling to insulate and wire the framing above the large, airy public space. After cleaning and re-staining the beams, Tad says, “I shot ‘em with polyurethane and hung ‘em back up.” Ashes were flowing from the room’s massive fireplace when the job began, so Tad rebuilt the firebox flue line and replaced its broken damper with a stainless steel door. A cast-iron Juliet balcony rail, overlooking this room from the upstairs hallway, was one of the few details that required no restoration.

    The living room’s rustic ceiling beams were carefully removed and reinstalled.

    The living room’s rustic ceiling beams were carefully removed and reinstalled.

    With the Preservation Board’s approval, the crew also created a rear addition with a master suite, upstairs laundry, and spa shower. Tad built the addition to the highest energy specifications, but he says the retrofit on the historic section proved to be no more of a construction challenge than building from scratch. “If you have the opportunity to open up the walls, you can do pretty darn well,” Tom says. (Because the home’s original interior was in such bad shape, the walls had to be rebuilt anyway.) Although he was referring to the effort to improve efficiency, Tom was equally successful in the pains he took to maintain historic elements.

    “The house is a hands-on example,” says Liz Safanda, chair of the local Preservation Partners of the Fox Valley. “You can lecture in the abstract, but this is a case study—windows, masonry, public façades, and a compatible addition. To have something visible and tangible, it really adds to the theoretical discussions.”

    The data from Tony Botkin’s efficiency tests show that the house’s consumption is nearly 70 percent below its pre-renovation levels. Factor that in to the resources and energy already embodied in an existing structure, and it’s easy to see why Tom suggests that an efficient retrofit—rather than airtight new construction—is the more sustainable choice. “You don’t have to get rid of a piece of history and all the culture that comes along with it,” he says. “You don’t have to lose your home.”

    Bonus Photo Gallery!

    Get more information on how the crew increased energy efficiency while maintaining the house’s historic features.

    Published in: Old-House Journal August/September 2011

    { 5 comments… read them below or add one }

    Tom Bassett-Dilley June 7, 2011 at 4:39 pm

    I wanted to write a few clarifications:
    - my firm is Tom Bassett-Dilley Architect, Ltd., not Drawing On Place;
    - Marko Spiegel of CTI, LaFox, IL, brought the Passive House concept to the project, though that approach was rejected by the owners for complexity and interior space concerns;
    - The project now does not approach the Passive House Retrofit standard, but is a good conventional retrofit, suitable for many historic houses;
    - We used 3/4″ furring strips on the walls, and they aren’t quite deep enough to eliminate thermal bridging (approx. R-5 min. is req’d. and we have about R-2.5)
    - Operational energy is far more significant than embodied energy in the lifetime of a building, so every effort should be made to maximize insulation and airtightness when possible (when will the next gut rehab be?);
    - Mechanical ventilation with heat recovery is an important aspect of healthy interiors, especially as the envelope gets more airtight.

    Scott June 8, 2011 at 2:42 pm

    I’m so glad I stumbled onto this article. This is an incredible house. A truly spectacular job! I actually used to drive past this house everyday on my way to work on saw the demise of this property over the years and often thought it would be an amazing house to rehab. Sadly many historic houses in the area in disrepair seem to be torn down and a piece of history is forever lost. I’m very grateful that you have taken the history of the community into consideration and given it new life. These old houses have so much character and thoughtfulness that’s hard to find in many modern homes. Great work!

    Catherine Brooks September 30, 2011 at 2:01 pm

    To expand on the “rehabilitation of windows”, here is more detail on what that involves with double-hung, wooden windows. It is truly a labor of love for homeowners to do this work. But the final results are worth it. Usually, the sashes are removed from the wall to make it easier to do the rehab. The wood rot must be repaired, the peeling paint removed and replaced, and sometimes the ropes or chains holding the weights must be changed. The glass panes’ glazing putty is often rock-solid, dry, and sporadic preventing the original seals from doing their job. The glazing compound needs to be completely removed above and below the glass, and new, tight seals made. The most challenging is how to do all this while preserving as much of the old wood and mechanisms as possible. In the last decade, new technologies have made these enhancements stronger, more long-lasting, and greener. Repair epoxies and paint removal methods have improved. First, torches, heat guns, and heat plates were used for decades but they operated at high very temperatures and put the wood at risk for scorching and even fire; they vaporized the toxic lead in the old paint endangering the workers and the building itself. Low temperature, infrared heat for paint removal was perfected in the 1990′s. It softens the glass glazing as well releases the paint for safe removal. Both removal processes are gentler on the wood than older methods. In addition, the low, evenly-distributed infrared heat makes glass breakage rare. With new glazing air-tight, gaping holes in the wood closed, and weight pockets sealed, the energy efficiency of the sash itself is creating improved energy efficiency and the beauty of the original window is reclaimed. See and read more eco-strip.com

    Tracy July 7, 2013 at 11:47 am

    Hello! Where did you find the storm door? I have an arched entry door and have been looking for quite a while. Gorgeous home and a very impressive transformation. Thank you!

    David Edrington, Archtiect October 21, 2014 at 6:13 pm

    I applaud the great effort to save this house and the sensitivity to the details as well as energy conservation. However, if I’ve read the article correctly, the windows have been made inoperable. This was a very inhumane decision and I think in violation of the otherwise careful attention to the historic details. The architectural character of the windows is not just in how they look, but how they function for the house.

    Leave a Comment



    Get your FREE Trial Issue of Old House Journal and a FREE gift.
    Yes! Please send me a FREE trial issue of Old House Journal and a FREE gift.
    If I like it and decide to continue, I'll get 7 more issues (8 in all) for just $16.95, a savings of 53%. If for any reason I decide not to continue,
    I'll write cancel on the invoice and owe nothing. The Free Trial Issue is mine to keep, no matter what.
     
     Full Name:
     Address 1:
     Address 2:
     City:
     State:
     Zip Code:
     Email (req):
     
    Offer valid in US only.
    Click here for Canada or here for international subscriptions

    Products & ServicesHouse ToursHistoric PlacesHouse StylesOldHouseOnline.comMagazine
    Architectual ElementsKitchen & BathsHistoric HotelsArchitectural TermsRepairs & How ToSubscribe to Old-House Journal
    BathsInterior & DécorHistoric NeighborhoodsAmerican FoursquareFree NewslettersBack Issues
    Ceilings & WallsGardens & ExteriorsHouse MuseumsBungalowSubscribe to Arts & Crafts HomesDigital Editions
    Doors & WindowsColonial RevivalOld House CommunityAdvertise
    Exterior Products & LandscapeGothicAbout Us 
    FlooringQueen AnneContact Us 
    FurnitureVictorianPrivacy Policy
    HardwareLand for Sale
    Heating & CoolingSite Map
    Home Décor
    Kitchens
    Period Lighting
    Real Estate
    Repair & Restoration
    Roofing & Siding
    Tools & Equipment

    EXPLORE OUR HOME GROUP BRANDS:
     
    Designer Sourcw e bookDesigner Craftsman Historic Home Show Logo

    Copyright © 2011-2014 Old House Online