An Outhouse Or An Addition?

A dissonant addition.
Author:
Publish date:
Updated on
remuddling

"The executive outhouse look is so trendy!" —Brian Jeffries

Don’t. . . confuse an addition and an outbuilding. A modern addition can be successful, but not if everything is incompatible with the original: rooflines, windows, cladding material, storey breaks, color, and vibe.

Creeping Up Behind
“I pass this bungalow every time I take a walk,” says a neighbor, “and it still stops me in my tracks. I gauge my mood by whether [the addition] that day strikes me as humorous, or tragic.” The best that can be said is that the new section steps back from the original house. But then it takes a bite out of it.

Preservationist John Leeke points out that the bungalow’s primary facade is intact, and that the addition can be removed in the future without serious damage. Still, what’s the story behind this design? For a time, the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation were interpreted as meaning that additions should not mimic the original. That is, new work should be differentiated, in part to avoid future confusion regarding the historical record. That’s easy enough to accomplish without creating such dissonance. A small variance in framing method, sash configuration, or cornice detailing keeps the record straight.

Related Articles

Products of the Week

Brookside

Pewabic Pottery

Pewabic fabricates heirloom quality architectural tiles for public and private installations, gift and commemorative tiles, vessels, gardenware, ornaments and both reproductions and adaptations of its historic designs and offers classes, workshops, lectures, internships and residency programs for studio potters and other artists.

vintage-doors-june7th-2019

Vintage Doors

Bring beauty and value your home with heirloom-quality REAL wood doors by Vintage Doors. Meticulously handmade by expert craftsmen in your exact size and style—to be loved and respected for generations, just like the olden days. Hand-crafted wood product line includes: screen doors, storm doors, Dutch doors, French doors, louver doors, pantry doors, interior doors, exterior doors, entrance units, three season porch enclosures, pet doors, arch top doors, round top doors, custom doors and more.

1_gallery_custom1

Unico System

A central heating and cooling system using "aspiration" technology to warm and cool homes evenly and quietly with flexible small ducts that weave through ceilings, walls, and even floors.