“It was a disaster,” Mary Seelaus freely admits of the 19th-century Colonial Revival home she and her husband, Jere, purchased almost two decades ago. An owner in the 1950s had decimated much of the original character of the house, ripping out built-ins and covering up fireplaces; just before Mary and Jere took over the house, a contractor had abandoned it halfway through another renovation—but not before he removed most of the original plumbing fixtures and replaced them with cheap builder stock. “There wasn’t a whole lot left when we came on the scene,” says Mary.
Still, the couple fell in love with the home’s location in a historic neighborhood in the sleepy Philadelphia suburb of Maple Glen, and were impressed by its pedigree—the home was remodeled to its current Colonial Revival appearance in 1896 by Horace Trumbauer, the prominent Philadelphia architect whose firm designed several high-profile commissions in the city, including the Philadelphia Art Museum.