A Mantel Makeover

A vintage piece reverses an unfortunate earlier remodeling of the fireplace.

 A ca. 1920 oak mantel found in England became the new focal point in the 1910 bungalow. More salvaged pieces were set around it: a vintage garden gate repurposed as a firescreen and an arched window frame hung on the wall above.

 A ca. 1920 oak mantel found in England became the new focal point in the 1910 bungalow. More salvaged pieces were set around it: a vintage garden gate repurposed as a firescreen and an arched window frame hung on the wall above.

Dan Mayers

When Roy Morton bought his 1910 bungalow in Birmingham, Alabama, adding a period-appropriate mantel was on the project list. The fireplace had been updated with a modern configuration: flat stones set beneath a cedar beam as a mantelshelf, and a raised hearth below. Morton owns a salvage store and makes regular buying trips to England—where he found an Arts & Crafts mantel rescued from a 1920s house. The oak piece has its original, gently worn finish. Details include carving and small shelf niches to hold books or knick-knacks.

Owning a salvage store has its benefits: a rusty iron gate, refinished and retrofitted, became the firescreen. Roy Morton’s store is Architectural Heritage: architecturalheritage.com

A detail shows the mantel’s handsome carving and book niches. The original finish was conserved.

Dan Mayers

1. MODIFICATION
The old mantelpiece was too short to meet fire-code requirements (which set the distance the wood mantel needs to be kept from the firebox). Morton created plinths at the bottom of the “legs” to raise the height about a foot. The plinths are white oak, stained to match the mantel’s original, dark-oak finish. The wood was gently cleaned (Morton’s recommendation is Trewax Natural Orange Cleaner); always try cleansers first in a small, unobtrusive spot. After a buffing with a soft cloth, the mantel got a coat of Briwax in Tudor Brown.

2. THE HEARTH
A two-inch concrete bed was poured for the hearth and simple, gauged grey slate laid level. A light grey grout was chosen, and the slate was treated with a color-enhancer stone sealer in a matte finish, to protect against staining.

3. HANGING THE MANTEL
The wood mantel was securely attached to wall studs with 3″ wood screws, concealed with round oak plugs. Another option for hanging is to screw a horizontal beveled cleat to the wall studs (long point out), attach another cleat to the back of the mantel, and then slip it in place. It’s secure and the mantel will not twist or sag.

4. SLATE SURROUND
Gauged grey slate tiles were used as the surround, set above and below the firebox. A polymer-modified thinset mortar was applied to the wall, to which the slate tiles were affixed and secured with shims until set. The grout is the same grey as was used for the hearth. Once again, the slate was sealed for enhancement and protection.

The Firebox

Be sure to measure your firebox before you go shopping for a vintage mantel. Fire codes require wooden mantels be installed at least six inches above and to the sides of the firebox opening to prevent fires. Woodwork placed within 12 inches of the firebox cannot project more than 1/8″ for each 1″ from the opening. So be sure to have your measurements with you, and measure the mantel carefully before purchase. Consult with your contractor, too.


Tags: fireplace Mantels OHJ February 2019 salvage

By Brian D. Coleman

Brian D. Coleman, M.D., is the Editor-at-large for Arts and Crafts Homes and Old House Journal magazines and has written numerous articles on home design. His work has appeared in magazines ranging from Old House Journal to Period Living in the U.K. 

Product Recommendations

Here are some supplies and products we find essential. We may receive a commission from sales referred by our links; however, we have carefully selected these products for their usefulness and quality.


© Copyright 2021 Home Group, a division of Active Interest Media. All Rights Reserved.
P.O. Box 20730 Boulder, CO 80308