We all use a pillow every night, but we don’t put much thought into buying one. After all, each pillow is a fluffy, soft, rectangular, and white piece. However, if you consider buying one of the highest-rated pillows in 2023, you will see how it affects your life. Experts have always emphasized the importance of sleep. They say that insufficient sleep can reduce alertness and concentration, lower your learning ability, and lead to higher health problems. It would be best to have a nice pillow to avoid getting yourself into harmful troubles. When buying a pillow, you need to consider a few factors like how much support it can provide to your neck, the quality, its price, and softness. Thus, to reduce the hassle, we have compiled a list of the best pillows. So, keep reading to get hold of a comprehensive buying guide.
Pillows are standard products that are a part of our day-to-day lives and usually aren’t given much thought. Oftentimes, you only think about pillows when it is time to replace them. Sleepline co-founder Robert Pagano shares that “if you use your pillows every day and wash them once a week, then you should probably replace them every six months. But if you only use them once a month and wash them once a year, then you can probably get away with replacing them every two years.”
Are you looking to replace your pillow? If you have started shopping for the best pillow, you likely realize how tough things it is to find the perfect one for you. To help you make the right choice, we have created this informative buying guide.
What To Consider Before Buying a Pillow?
Sleeping position is an essential factor to consider because if you want to give your head and neck the best support, you will need a pillow that does not tilt your head too up or down. Consider if you are a back sleeper; it is best to get a flatter pillow than the side sleepers. Stomach sleepers need a thin pillow that does not push their necks high. The key to a peaceful sleep is to have your neck and spine at a neutral angle as it relieves the stress from both. Some sleepers don’t have a fixed sleeping position, and they tend to roll between sleeping on their back and lying to the side. Such sleepers need a pillow that is not too firm nor too plushy. It is best to get a pillow according to the position you initially fall asleep in.
Type of mattress
Many users don’t bother about considering the type of mattress, but it is an essential factor. If you have a firm mattress, you need a fuller pillow. On the other hand, it is best to get a thinner pillow if you have a soft mattress. A softer mattress will make your body sink into it, so there is not much gap between the mattress and your head, so a thin pillow will keep your neck and spine aligned. On the other hand, a firm mattress allows a large gap between the mattress and the user’s head, so you need a pillow to fill the void accordingly.
Some people are allergic to specific fabrics and fillings. So, you cannot sleep in peace on a pillow that makes you uncomfortable. For instance, some people are allergic to buckwheat and latex, so they need to avoid such pillow filling. Similarly, some people react to dust mites that tend to live on a synthetic pillow, so they need a natural filling pillow. If you buy a pillow stuffed with bird feathers, you need to make your pick carefully and choose one free of bird allergens. Bird allergens include mites and dust.
You can also see if the pillow is made of hypoallergenic material. However, there are no particular standards for hypoallergenic material, so it is best to browse the product description. The product description or label will tell you about the pillow’s filling and make sure that it does not contain anything you are allergic to.
We can’t deny that this pillow has set a benchmark. If you consider the product’s price, you will be amazed to see the comfort level. The lavish gel fiber makes the pillow suitable for hot sleepers and keeps the pillow soft without making it lose its firmness. The mold-ability and firmness of a pillow should be balanced with the softness to be comfortable and support the neck. Beckham has established this balance beautifully. Although these pillows lack height adjustment factors, users do have not many complaints about their sleeping positions. All the credit goes to the no-shift construction design that helps the pillow maintain its shape throughout the night.
Very affordable for a pack of 2
Extremely comfortable and soft
Maintain its firmness and shape
30-day trial period with a complete money-back guarantee
The Diamond Elegant Bed Pillows are a set that gives you the best bang for your money. This is because this option comes as a set of four pillows, which makes it by far the most affordable option on our list. These pillows feature a down-alternative cluster fiber fill encased inside a 100% cotton pillowcase, have an optimal loft, and are designed to bounce back just like ones with an actual down filling. The fill is also siliconized to prevent migration or clumping after washing, meaning you get to enjoy the same support and comfort. Even better, the pillowcase is diamond embossed, yet extremely smooth and soft, and it is made more elegant with the long staple yarns that weave all over it.
It’s a known fact that humans can’t function right without proper sleep, and if you have a wonky pillow, getting that deep 8-hour sleep becomes next to impossible. That’s why we’d suggest investing in a firm and fluffy pillow like Oubonun’s Premium Adjustable Pillow to get that comfortable sleep that your body sorely needs.
Its adjustable loft is also perfect for unorthodox sleepers that find it difficult to get uninterrupted sleep on a standard pillow. It has a breathable, skin-friendly cotton pillowcase that will leave you feeling fresh and dandy in the morning, ready to take on any challenges that life throws. Lastly, its easy and flexible polyester material makes it perfect for machine washing and drying without any extra hassle.
Adjustable loft for added comfort
Made from breathable and comfortable cotton
Machine washing and drying enhances its fluffiness
The next pillow in the queue is from Dream Rite, and it contains 60% polyester and 40% viscose. The pillow is available in two sizes: king size and queen size. Dream Rite has crafted the pillow from 80% shredded memory foam and 20% polyester to provide extreme comfort. Thus, you don’t need to worry about neck pain after prolonged sleeping hours. The best part is that you can adjust the height according to your comfort. The filling is removable so that you can customize it. Whether you prefer a soft pillow or firm, you can manage it yourself. The fabric for making the pillow has such quality that it stays cool for many hours and allows breathability, making the user feel fresh and peaceful. The company has also taken care of sensitivity. The pillow is hypoallergenic and can be easily washed in the machine. However, it is best to tumble dry the pillow on low heat every six months.
Coop Home Goods is a well-known brand certified by the GreenGuard Gold Institute. Users love this cross-cut memory foam pillow for its quality and comfort, as it’s made from 60% polyester and 40% bamboo viscose rayon. The manufacturers claim that the pillow is suitable for any sleeper as it is entirely adjustable. You can remove or add memory foam according to your comfort. By adding the foam fill according to your choice, you can customize the pillow and be in complete control. Users love the ½ lb bag of additional stuffing that comes with the pillow. The company also says that its product is cruelty-free as no animals were harmed while making it.
½ lb additional memory foam is sent with pillows
Extremely soft and comfortable
Height and shape can be adjusted according to comfort
Here is another pair of certified pillows from Viewstar. The pillows are certified by OEKO-TEX for their compatibility with your sleeping requirements. Users have reported that these pillows are allergen-free and skin-friendly. Thus, people with sensitive skin can also use the pillows without any tension. The pillow also maintains its breathability throughout the night. The stylish gusset of the Viewstar pillows has caught customers’ attention as it makes the bedding look more classy and appealing. Many hotel owners prefer buying these pillows as they have a luxurious design suitable for their customers. Lastly, it is available in three sizes: queen, king, and standard.
Microfiber adds extra plumpness
Suitable for hotel use
OEKO-TEX has certified the pillows
Ideal for all kinds of sleepers
It does not help in relieving back and shoulder pain
Last but not least is the Utopia bedding pillows available in three different sizes, and various color options are also available. The pillow has fiber filling and neat stitching for enhanced durability and quality. The professionally tailored edges show the product’s quality and ensure the maximum level of comfort. The architectural design of the pillows is perfect for relieving stress from your pressure points and allows you to sleep peacefully.
The pillow has gusset microfibers
Enhanced durability with double stitching
You can easily wash it in a machine
The pillow is incredibly soft, so some users feel like their head is sinking into it.
People Also Asked
Q: What is the difference between polyester pillows and memory foam?
A: Memory foam pillows are generally denser than polyester pillows, so they typically conform to the shape of your head.
Q: How to see if a pillow maintains its shape?
A: Sometimes pillows lose their shape when you sleep on them regularly, so to test it, you can fluff the pillow before buying and see if it gets back in its original shape.
Q: Which pillows are breathable?
A: The denser the pillow, the less breathable it will be, so look for pillows with pieces of filling like polyester, foam chunks, or feathers.
Q: Can I put a pillow in the washing machine?
A: Most pillows are safe to put in the washing machine on warm and gentle settings. It is important to read the cleaning instructions on the label of your pillow.
Q: How often should I wash my pillow?
A: You should wash your pillow every 6 months. If your pillow starts to turn yellow or smell, you should wash it sooner.
The Old House Journal Review Team’s product reviews and in-depth guides are here to help you restore, repair, update, and decorate your home. The content is created by The Old House Journal Review Team. The Old House Journal editorial staff is not involved. Old House Journal is reader-supported: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Expert Contributions By Robert Pagano
Robert Pagano is the co-founder of Sleepline. As someone who has struggled with sleep for many years, he has extensive experience with various sleep products and treatments. His main goal is to give you straightforward info on what works and doesn’t work so you can get back to your life without spending the same time and effort that he did.