logo
logo
  • Home
  • Products & Services
  • How-To
  • House Tours
  • Gardens & Exteriors
  • Kitchens & Baths
  • Interiors & Decors
  • Magazines
  • Buying Guides
    • Attic
    • Basement
    • Bed & Bath
    • Bedroom
    • Cleaning
    • Decks & Patios
    • Dining Room
    • Exterior Design
    • Garage
    • Home Office
    • Kitchen & Dining
    • Outdoor & Garden
    • Living Room
    • Smart Home
    • Home Improvement
    • Utilities
  • Reviews
  • Bedroom
We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products-learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

Enjoy Comfort and Support With the Best Queen Mattresses

author-image
By Old House Journal Review Team
Last updated: 13 Feb 2023

A good night’s sleep is essential for leading a healthy and productive life, and one of the key factors that contribute to good sleep is a quality mattress. With its ample size and comfortable design, a queen mattress can provide you with the perfect balance of space and support you need for a great night’s sleep.

Whether you’re a side sleeper, a back sleeper, or a stomach sleeper, a queen mattress can adapt to your position, ensuring that your body is properly aligned and you wake up feeling refreshed. Don’t know where to start? Don’t worry! We’ve compiled a list of the top queen mattresses of 2023 to help you enjoy restful nights. 

Best Overall
logo
Leesa Queen Mattress
Check on Amazon
Most Comfortable
logo
Casper Queen Mattress
Check on Amazon
Most Supportive
logo
Tuft & Needle Queen Mattress
Check on Amazon
Most Durable
logo
Sealy Queen Mattress
Check on Amazon
Most Affordable
logo
Sleep Innovations Queen Mattress
Check on Amazon

Finding a Quality Queen Mattress: A Buyer's Guide

Quality sleep is essential for your overall well-being and physical and mental health. A good night’s sleep not only helps you feel refreshed and rejuvenated in the morning but also improves your focus, productivity, and mood throughout the day. 

A comfortable and supportive mattress is a key component of a sleep-conducive environment, and choosing the right one can make all the difference in getting the restful sleep you need. With the multitude of options available, it can be difficult to select the ideal queen mattress. So, to make your search easier, we prepared this comprehensive guide to help you choose a mattress that suits your needs.  

How To Pick the Right Queen Mattress

Size 

When selecting a queen-size mattress, consider the length, width, and depth. The standard dimensions for a queen mattress are 60 inches wide and 80 inches long, with most models ranging between 6 and 12 inches in depth. 

Firmness level 

There are three different levels of firmness (firm, medium, soft) that provide different levels of comfort and support. Firm mattresses provide more support but can feel less comfortable than softer ones. Medium mattresses offer a balance between comfort and support, while soft mattresses may feel more comfortable but may not provide the same level of support. Consider which feel is best for you based on your sleeping habits and needs.

Motion isolation 

When sleeping with a partner, motion isolation is an important factor to consider. Look for mattresses that evenly distribute your weight and reduce motion transfer, ensuring one person’s movements don’t disturb the other. 

Edge support 

Edge support prevents sagging near the edges of the mattress and keeps the surface consistently supportive throughout the night. Make sure your chosen mattress provides adequate edge support for even weight distribution across its entire surface. 

Breathability

Look for a queen mattress made with breathable materials that keep air circulating throughout the structure. This will ensure that your body temperature stays regulated during sleep so you can remain cool and comfortable throughout the night. 

Material type 

There are four main types of materials used in mattress construction — foam, latex, hybrid, and innerspring — each of which provides different levels of comfort and support. 

Foam mattresses offer contouring and pressure relief, while latex mattresses provide more bounce and breathability. Hybrid mattresses combine foam and innerspring layers for balanced comfort and support, and innerspring mattresses offer more springiness but less contouring than foam materials. Think about what type of feel and level of support you prefer when making your decision. 

Comfort layer 

Comfort layers give your body cushioning and contouring while also providing pressure relief. Look for mattresses with high-quality comfort layers made from breathable materials such as memory or gel-infused foam. 

Warranty and trial period 

Most mattress manufacturers provide warranties that cover defects or malfunctions that occur during normal mattress use over time. Additionally, many brands offer trial periods with money-back guarantees so that you can test out the mattress before committing to it fully. 

Benefits of Using a Queen Mattress

Improved comfort

One of the key benefits of using a queen mattress is improved comfort. A queen-sized mattress provides ample space for people to move freely, allowing for comfortable sleep without feeling cramped or confined. 

Better support

A high-quality queen mattress provides excellent support for a good night’s sleep. Its support mattress can help reduce aches and pains, prevent spinal misalignment, and promote good posture, leading to a more comfortable and restful sleep. 

Mattresses with good support also have a longer lifespan, as they are less prone to sagging and other wear and tear issues. High-quality queen mattresses are available with a variety of support systems, including innerspring coils, memory foam, and hybrid designs, making it easy to find a mattress that provides the right level of support for individual needs.

Better sleep quality

Using a high-quality queen mattress can improve the quality of one’s sleep, leading to better overall health and well-being. It helps reduce the tossing and turning that can disturb sleep, as well as improve sleep quality by reducing the stress on the body, allowing for more restful and rejuvenating sleep.

Comparing the Top Queen Mattress of 2023 in Detail

1

Leesa Queen Mattress

– Best Overall
img
Buy on Amazon

The Leesa Original Hybrid Queen Mattress is a luxurious mattress that provides superb support. Its unique combination of premium foam and responsive pocket springs creates the optimal environment for a good night’s sleep. The mattress also offers the perfect balance between pressure relief and support, while the soft and stylish gray twill cover adds an extra layer of comfort and luxury.

This queen mattress is made with high-quality materials and comes with a 100-night trial to ensure it meets your sleep needs. Even more, this mattress has a memory foam recovery layer on top that creates a contouring effect to keep sleepers comfortable throughout the night. Meanwhile, its breathable design helps keep cool air circulating underneath as you rest.  

Overall, this mattress is perfect for those looking for a supportive night’s sleep without sacrificing any of the luxury associated with a high-end mattress. This queen mattress is our top choice because it offers everything you need for a restful sleeping experience with its unique combination of responsiveness, breathability, and superior comfort.

Pros
  • Provides good edge support
  • Firm and comfortable 
  • High-quality hybrid mattress
  • Cooling foam for excellent support and comfort 
Cons
  • Some find it too firm
2

Casper Queen Mattress

– Most Comfortable
img
Buy on Amazon

The Casper Original Queen Mattress is ideal for those looking for a comfortable night’s sleep. It features a combination of proprietary materials that work together to ensure you get the best rest possible. Plus, the mattress has three zones of targeted support to help align your spine and promote good posture while sleeping. 

The top layer of perforated breathable foam aids in temperature regulation, and the tiny pores in the foam direct hot air away from the body to keep you comfortable throughout the night. Additionally, softer foam around the shoulders provides comfort for the upper body, and firmer foam under the hips, waist, and lower back helps keep the spine aligned. Supportive and breathable, this queen mattress is essential for a restful night’s sleep and is an overall terrific choice. 

Pros
  • Excellent spinal alignment and posture support
  • Provides relief from aches and pains
  • Can handle a lot of use 
Cons
  • Off-gassing odor can last a while
3

Tuft & Needle Queen Mattress

– Most Supportive
img
Buy on Amazon

The Tuft & Needle Original Queen Mattress is designed to provide a firm yet comfortable sleeping surface. It features an adaptive foam layer that is engineered for maximum pressure relief and adjusts to the sleeper’s position as they move throughout the night. Underneath the adaptive foam layer is a supportive base layer that helps prevent sinking into the mattress. 

The open-cell cooling technology foam, graphite, and cooling gel incorporated into the adaptive foam work together to remove excess heat and moisture from your body, allowing you to sleep more soundly and comfortably. Further, this queen mattress is so adaptable that it may be used with a wide range of bed frames, including box springs, platform beds, slatted bed bases, bunk beds, and even adjustable ones.  

Pros
  • Provides excellent support  
  • Adaptive foam provides pressure relief
  • Easy setup, no assembly required
Cons
  • May be too firm for some
4

Sealy Queen Mattress

– Most Durable
img
Buy on Amazon

The Sealy Queen Mattress is the perfect choice for anyone looking for a quality mattress that can be conveniently delivered right to their door. This pick arrives compressed and ready to go, with a full expansion within 24 to 72 hours. Additionally, it boasts layers of memory foam designed to hug your body and provide personalized night-long comfort, all while ensuring you’re supported with firmer foam placed underneath. This means you’ll have all the comfort you need for a good night’s sleep.

Even better, this queen mattress also features CopperChill technology which promotes cooler, more comfortable sleep. So, no matter what your sleeping style is, this medium memory foam mattress will keep you at just the right temperature throughout the night. A compressible design, long-lasting materials, and certified safe foams make this a great choice for anyone looking for a durable mattress that arrives ready to use in just a few days. 

Pros
  • Soft, plush feel
  • Keeps you cool while you sleep
  • No off-gassing odor 
Cons
  • Doesn’t inflate properly
5

Sleep Innovations Queen Mattress

– Most Affordable
img
Buy on Amazon

The Sleep Innovations Shiloh Queen Mattress is a perfect choice for anyone looking for a comfortable and supportive sleeping experience. This mattress features a soft knit cover, vented Suretemp memory foam, and a sturdy base layer to provide pressure-relieving, medium-firm support for those with different sleeping styles. 

This mattress is made with eco-conscious materials and is hypoallergenic, breathable, and CertiPUR-US certified, ensuring you get the best quality sleep possible. The mattress arrives in a box and it only takes 24 to 72 hours for the mattress to take its full shape in warmer temperatures. If the room temperature is cold, it may take longer to return to its original size. For those looking to upgrade their sleep experience, this queen mattress offers comfort and superior support without breaking the bank.

Pros
  • Adapts to your body shape 
  • Does not sink 
  • Comes with a 10-year warranty
  • Offers firm support for neck and back
Cons
  • Has a strong smell initially

People Also Asked

Q: Does a queen mattress provide enough support for two people?

A: Yes, a queen mattress provides enough support for two people as it’s designed with supportive layers that help to distribute weight evenly on the bed. It also has enough room to comfortably fit two people, making it a great choice for couples.

Q: Are queen mattresses good for back problems?

A: Yes, queen mattresses are generally very supportive and can benefit those suffering from back problems. Look for a mattress with the right combination of layers and surface textures that provide both support and comfort, as well as contouring that helps support your body’s natural curves and alignment.

Q: What are the key differences between all queen mattresses?

A: Queen mattresses vary in terms of the type of coil system used (innerspring or pocket-spring) and the comfort levels of their layers, such as foam, latex, or memory foam. Additionally, some beds are adjustable, allowing users to customize their sleeping experience by adjusting the firmness of their mattress. The price of the mattress will also vary depending on its construction and features. 

Q: How long should a queen mattress last?

A: For optimal comfort and support, it is recommended that you replace your queen mattress every eight to 10 years. After this time, the materials in the mattress may start to wear down, making it less supportive and comfortable to sleep on.

Q: What type of bed frame should I use with my queen mattress?

A: When choosing a bed frame for your queen mattress, it is important to ensure that the frame matches the size and shape of your mattress. Most queen mattresses measure 60 x 80 inches, meaning you should opt for a frame that can support this size comfortably without sagging. You could also opt for an adjustable bed frame that allows you to customize various aspects, such as the head and foot position, for extra personalization.

author-image
By Old House Journal Review Team
The Old House Journal Review Team’s product reviews and in-depth guides are here to help you restore, repair, update, and decorate your home. The content is created by The Old House Journal Review Team. The Old House Journal editorial staff is not involved. Old House Journal is reader-supported: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Related Reviews
img
Keep Your Mattress in Tip-top Shape With the Aller-Ease Mattress Protector
img
Soft or Firm: What Is the Ideal Mattress for Great Sleep?
img
Reduce Night Sweats With the Best Cooling Mattress Protectors
img
Extend Your Mattress’ Life With the Best Mattress Protectors
  • Subscribe to Magazine
  • Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Get Your Company Listed
  • Digital Editions
  • Subscription Services
  • Renew Subscription
  • Give a Gift
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising
  • Sister Sites
  • Traditional Building
  • Period Homes
  • Arts & Crafts Homes
  • Log Home Living
  • Woodsmith
  • Timber Home Living
  • Popular Woodworking
  • Horticulture
  • Cuisine at Home
  • Writers Digest
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
© 2023 Old House Journal