logo
logo
  • Home
  • Products & Services
  • How-To
  • House Tours
  • Gardens & Exteriors
  • Kitchens & Baths
  • Interiors & Decors
  • Magazines
  • Buying Guides
    • Attic
    • Basement
    • Bed & Bath
    • Bedroom
    • Cleaning
    • Decks & Patios
    • Dining Room
    • Exterior Design
    • Garage
    • Home Office
    • Kitchen & Dining
    • Outdoor & Garden
    • Living Room
    • Smart Home
    • Home Improvement
    • Utilities
  • Reviews
  • Bed & Bath
Last updated: 7 Mar 2023
We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products-learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

Make Your Bed Cozy and Classy With the Best Cotton Sheets

Most Comfy
Sleep Mantra Cotton Sheets
Check on Amazon
Check Price On Walmart
Most Premium
Threadmill Cotton Sheets
Check on Amazon
Best Variety
Eddie Bauer Cotton Sheets
Check on Amazon
Most Eco-Friendly
Pizuna Cotton Sheets
Check on Amazon
Softest Feel
California Design Den Cotton Sheets
Check on Amazon
Most Elegant
Pinzon Cotton Sheets
Check on Amazon
Best Hypoallergenic
Mayfair Linen Cotton Sheets
Check on Amazon
Highest Thread Count
Comfy Sheets Cotton Sheets
Check on Amazon
author-image
By Old House Journal Review Team
Published 3:41 pm

Bed sheets crafted from cotton fiber are often the most comfortable and longest-lasting. They are soft, lightweight, breathable, and durable, even after years of machine washing. Some options are made with sateen-cotton blends or Egyptian cotton yarn, while others might be crafted from velvet and cotton material.

With this wide variety of factors to evaluate, it might be confusing to search for a good set of cotton sheets — especially considering the number of products available. To help you find the optimal set, we have put together a list of the finest cotton sheets in 2023. There’s also a comprehensive buying guide that covers advice and tips on choosing the right option for your needs. Without any more delay, let’s uncover the features of these top-quality sheets.

Comparing the Top Cotton Sheets of 2023

1

Sleep Mantra Cotton Sheets

– Most Comfy

The Sleep Mantra Cotton Sheets are a soft, light, and airy collection, perfect for the hot summer months. The twin-size set comes with one flat sheet, one elasticized fitted sheet, and one regular pillowcase. The fitted sheet stays secure and features convenient head and foot labeling to make putting it on easy. The elegant touch of the contrasting hem pattern completes the stylish look of this bedding set. 

Even better, both children and adults can appreciate these sheets’ relaxed fit and soft material. With a percale weave, this option allows air to pass through, making them comfortable in any season. The sheets are made with natural dyes that have a minimal environmental impact. Those with sensitive skin can also rest easy, knowing no harmful chemicals are present in this product that could harm the skin. If you don’t want your cotton sheets to be wrinkly, remove them as soon as the machine cycle is over.

Pros
  • Easy to clean and put on
  • Unique and thoughtful eco-friendly gift
  • Lightweight and long-lasting construction
Cons
  • Some may find the material thin
2

Threadmill Cotton Sheets

– Most Premium

Get only the best night’s sleep with the Threadmill Cotton Sheets. The 100% pure cotton and sateen weave will provide you with the softest, most comfortable sleeping experience. This 600-thread count set is super breathable so you won’t feel sweaty sleeping on these sheets night after night. The interwoven sateen design adds a beautiful, long-lasting shine to the sheets at a great price you can’t beat. Not only do these cotton sheets feel great but they look it, too.

This set includes one flat sheet, one fitted sheet, and two standard pillowcases, so you can be surrounded by a cloud of softness. The elastic bottom sheet has a sizable deep pocket to fit many types of mattresses. All you have to do is pull, tuck, and relax! The premium quality cannot be understated, but the ease of use and washing is also a bonus. Simply throw these cotton sheets in the washer in warm or cool water, dry them on a low cycle, and put them on immediately to prevent wrinkles. The high-quality fabric of this option shouldn’t pill, fade, or rip over time. 

Pros
  • Super snug fit
  • Premium quality fabric for long-lasting use
  • Easy to wash and put on
Cons
  • Must follow care instructions
3

Eddie Bauer Cotton Sheets

– Best Variety

These cotton percale sheets are handwoven for getting the perfect and smooth finish. Besides, their lightweight texture and softness make them ideal for sensitive skin. Since they are crafted from pure cotton with a 200 thread count, they are more durable, breathable, and will become delicate after every wash. 

Another prominent feature of this cotton sheet set is that it is reinforced with deep pockets and premium elastic to perfectly fit your mattress. This collection includes one flat sheet, one fitted sheet, and two standard-size pillow covers. Finally, to meet your style standards, these cotton sheets are available in five different sizes as well as various colors and designs.

Pros
  • Ideal for all-season use
  • Made from 100% cotton for optimal comfort
  • Non-slip design featuring durable elastic
  • Suitable for sensitive skin
Cons
  • May wrinkle after long-term use
  • Could be difficult to get your preference
4

Pizuna Cotton Sheets

– Most Eco-Friendly

Pizuna is one of the most reputable USA-based bed sheet brands on the market. A perfect example of their impressive quality is these amazing 100% cotton bed sheets that get softer after each and every wash. Completely chemical-free, the certified AZO-free and eco-friendly materials allow you to reduce your overall carbon footprint while also prioritizing your skin’s health.

The long-staple cotton sateen weave ensures a distinctively cool feel to the sheets and additional breathability that makes them comfortable all year long.

Pros
  • 100% long-staple cotton offers extra breathability
  • Excellent temperature balancing
  • Easy to machine wash on a gentle cycle
  • Environmentally-friendly construction
Cons
  • May be slightly bigger than advertised
5

California Design Den Cotton Sheets

– Softest Feel

Make your bed extra comfy with these ultra-soft cotton sheets. Constructed with pure cotton fiber and a fabulous sateen weave, these bed sheets retain their delicate feel for a long time. Their color also won’t fade even after long-term use. The 360-degree elastic and smart foot indicators also help you fit the cotton sheets perfectly on your bed. 

In addition, the dyes are entirely free from harmful chemicals and these bed covers are manufactured by following an eco-friendly process. For your convenience, you can clean them with regular hand washing or in the washing machine. This set includes one flat sheet, one fitted bed sheet, and two standard-size pillowcases.

Pros
  • Pick from a variety of colors and sizes
  • Crafted with a high thread count for durability 
  • Made from pure Egyptian cotton fiber
Cons
  • May require regular ironing to stay wrinkle-free
  • Some customers receive a different color
6

Pinzon Cotton Sheets

– Most Elegant

This beautiful cotton sheet set will add an elegant vibe to your bedroom. Made from 100% combed cotton and heavyweight velvet material, these bed covers are soft, durable, and skin-friendly. This option includes one flat sheet, one fitted bed sheet, and two standard-size pillow covers.

For perfect coverage, these cotton sheets come in different sizes, including standard, queen, king, and California king. You can also clean this set by regular hand washing or in the washing machine. In addition, their double-napped finish with a 190-gram flannel weight ensures long-lasting comfort and fabric that’s delicate on the skin.

Pros
  • Durable 4-inch hem design
  • Soft 100% cotton fiber and flannel velvet
  • Manufactured according to safety standards and eco-friendly methods
  • Enjoy extra softness after each wash
Cons
  • Not ideal for pet owners
  • Difficult to get your desired color
7

Mayfair Linen Cotton Sheets

– Best Hypoallergenic

Experience sound sleep on these super cozy bed sheets. Crafted with quality long-staple Egyptian cotton yarns, this bed cover set is long-lasting, luxurious, and breathable. On top of it, the 600 thread count adds additional thickness to these cotton sheets. Their anti-peeling property also saves you from pilling residue and makes the bed sheets last longer. After every wash, these cotton sheets should become softer while retaining their vibrant color.

Another significant feature of this cotton sheet set is its 15-inch deep pockets for an impeccable fit. This also prevents your sheets from slipping off the bed. Its hypoallergenic property makes it suitable for individuals with allergies. You can easily clean this cotton sheet set with regular hand washing or in the washing machine.

Pros
  • Manufactured in different sizes and colors
  • Anti-peeling feature for long-term use
  • Weaved with soft long-staple Egyptian cotton yarns
  • Color doesn’t fade, even after multiple washes
Cons
  • Some people find this option overpriced
  • May shrink after multiple washes
8

Comfy Sheets Cotton Sheets

– Highest Thread Count

Relax after a hectic schedule in your comfy bed with these cozy cotton sheets. Weaved with an 800 thread count, these cotton bedsheets are durable yet delicate. The 100% sateen Egyptian cotton and chemical-free dyes ensure this option is safe for your skin.

This set includes a flat bed sheet, a fitted bed cover, and two standard-size pillowcases. You can choose a color and size according to your requirements from a range of options. Unlike some low-quality bed sheets that deteriorate after washing, these cotton sheets are easy to wash and do not pill.

Pros
  • Comes in many different colors and sizes
  • High thread count for optimal comfort
  • Long-lasting and skin-friendly construction
  • Convenient to wash and put on
Cons
  • Hem may lose its elasticity after washing
  • Might wrinkle after drying
9

10

img

Buying Guide: Cotton Sheets

Bedsheets are a game-changer when it comes to decorating your bedroom and maximizing its comfort. Getting a high-quality cotton sheet set can feel a lot like searching for a needle in a haystack, however.

To save you from overwhelming confusion and wasting your valuable time, we have compiled a comprehensive buying guide to help you choose the right cotton sheets for your bed.

Why Should You Use Cotton Sheets?

Getting sound sleep leaves you feeling fresh and helps you to maintain good health. Many people struggle to sleep in today’s hectic life, however, and suffer from issues like insomnia. Difficulty sleeping or falling asleep is influenced by a variety of circumstances. It can be connected to excess stress, overworking, or even a bad bed! While it may seem obvious, your bed can play a huge role in why you face difficulty in sleeping and feel tired throughout the day. 

When talking about a good bed, we cannot avoid discussing bedsheets. Soft, smooth, and breathable cotton sheets can help you fall asleep sooner and also increase your deep-sleep time. Bed sheets made from pure cotton fibers are also skin-friendly and should not cause rashes or blisters. Another advantage of using beautifully designed cotton sheets is that they add an elegant touch to your bedroom. In general, cotton sheets can make your ordinary bedroom more comfortable and luxurious, allowing you to get better rest every night.

What Should You Consider While Shopping for a Cotton Sheet?

Material

Egyptian cotton yarn is one of the best materials for bed sheets. Materials like heavy velvet, sateen, and combed cotton are also popular for crafting premium cotton sheets. These materials are soft, smooth, and skin-friendly. A good material should ultimately absorb sweat, regulate temperature, and enhance your sleep cycle. So, make sure to examine the fabric details before finalizing your purchase.

Size and fit

The next crucial factor to focus on is the size of the cotton sheets. Most bed covers are available in a variety of sizes that fit most standard-size beds. Make sure to choose a bed sheet set according to your bed’s size; otherwise, you may end up wasting your money. A perfect-sized bed cover offers a non-slip fit that should save you from repeated bed-making. Deep pockets reinforced with highly stretchable and durable elastic can also help cotton sheets stay securely on the bed, no matter how much you move in your sleep. 

Thread count

The horizontal and vertical threads present in a square-inch area of a bed sheet are referred to as the thread count. Most cotton sheets have an average thread count ranging from 200 to 800. The greater the thread count, the denser the fabric cover.

This is one factor that determines the durability of your cotton sheets. It helps the bed sheets withstand wear and tear and save them from forming holes due to body friction. That’s why it’s essential to check the thread count of cotton sheets when purchasing a set.

Texture

A good cotton sheet set is soft, smooth, and cool in texture. It also should not wrinkle and cause itching to your body. A light-textured cotton sheet is breathable and does not clog your skin pores. In contrast, some poor-quality bed sheets are rough and hard, and can even cause rashes on your skin. They can also hinder your sleep cycle and leave you feeling tired every morning.

Some bed sheets are not ideal for pet owners. A certain texture may stubbornly catch your pet’s hair and leave you frustrated by the need for repetitive cleaning. Do not forget to check the texture of any cotton sheet before making your final choice.

Dyes

Another important factor to check while shopping for high-quality cotton sheets is the dyes used for coloring the fabric. Get your hands on bed covers that are pigmented with skin-friendly and toxic-free dyes. Some dyes tend to fade or spread their shade, leading to a damaged design and look of the cotton sheet. Make sure to look for ones manufactured with long-lasting dyes.

Design and color

Do you want dull or boring sheets on your bed? Of course, not. Bed sheets play an important role in making your bedroom luxurious and relaxing. Most cotton sheets are available in vibrant colors and prints. It’s a good idea to get your hands on a set that matches your bedroom wall color, curtains, or other similar items to fit the theme of the space. You can also go for light and cool colors as they create calm vibes and can help make you feel relaxed after a hectic day.

When Should You Replace and Change Cotton Sheets?

Most branded and top-quality cotton sheets can last for eight to 10 years. In contrast, some mediocre-quality cotton sheets last only for a few months or one to two years. Using two or more cotton sheet sets alternatively can increase the shelf life of the fabric overall. 

Dermatologists suggest changing and washing bed covers after every seven days of use. Our bodies shed dead skin cells while sleeping, so you must change the bed cover regularly to maintain good hygiene.

How To Maintain Cotton Sheets

Wash

Most bed sheets can be washed with regular detergent and soap. You can give them a hand wash or machine wash, depending on your preference. Some white bedsheets can also be bleached to retain brightness. Washing cotton sheets in cold water increases the softness and smoothness of the fabric. But before the first wash, make sure to read all the washing details mentioned on the product’s tag or page. Some sheets are also advised to wash separately for the first time as they may leach some extra color.

Store

You can keep bed covers in moisture-resistant zipper bags for long-lasting storage. You can also use butter paper which helps to retain the fabric texture and quality. Make sure to dry the sheets after every wash before storing them completely. You can also use fragrance sheets to keep them free from any foul odor. 

People Also Asked

Q: Can I wash cotton sheets using my washing machine?

A: Yes, most cotton sheets can be cleaned in a washing machine. You can also usually wash them with regular detergents and washing liquids. Still, make sure to check the washing care details of your cotton sheets before washing.

Q: Are cotton sheets good for skin?

A: Yes, good-quality cotton sheets woven from pure cotton yarn are skin-friendly. They should not cause skin rashes and are ideal for sensitive skin. They also help absorb body sweat and enhance your sleep time while giving you a comfy feeling.

Q: Can I iron my cotton sheets?

A: It can be a good idea to iron your cotton sheets can after washing them. Most bed sheets, however, are crafted from wrinkle-free fabric and don't need to be ironed to stay smooth.

Q: What is a good thread count for cotton sheets?

A: An optimal thread count between 300 and 500 is a good range of high-quality cotton sheets. While this can be a helpful factor, don't base your decision solely on it as some high thread counts may be falsely represented.

Q: Is Egyptian cotton better than regular cotton?

A: Recently, some fabric specialists have determined that cotton's origin can greatly impact its quality, lifespan, and durability. Egyptian cotton is generally deemed stronger and more flexible than regular cotton, making it an excellent choice for cotton sheets.

Bed Sheets Bedding Bedroom
author-image
By Old House Journal Review Team
The Old House Journal Review Team’s product reviews and in-depth guides are here to help you restore, repair, update, and decorate your home. The content is created by The Old House Journal Review Team. The Old House Journal editorial staff is not involved. Old House Journal is reader-supported: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Related Reviews
img
Finding The Best Bed Skirt For Your Bed
img
Enjoy a Good Night’s Sleep With The Best Deep Pocket Sheet
img
Sleep in Peace With the Best Bamboo Bed Sheets
img
Best Flannel Sheets to Keep You Warm in Cold Nights
  • Subscribe to Magazine
  • Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Get Your Company Listed
  • Digital Editions
  • Subscription Services
  • Renew Subscription
  • Give a Gift
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising
  • Sister Sites
  • Traditional Building
  • Period Homes
  • Arts & Crafts Homes
  • Log Home Living
  • Woodsmith
  • Timber Home Living
  • Popular Woodworking
  • Horticulture
  • Cuisine at Home
  • Writers Digest
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
© 2023 Old House Journal