Do you have difficulty falling asleep at night? Do you feel the need for an added layer of softness on your mattress that cushions and supports your spine? You need a good mattress topper to transform your bed into a sleep-friendly haven. A mattress topper not only enhances comfort but also protects the mattress, enhancing its durability and lifespan.
However, making this purchase can prove tricky since the market is brimming with a variety of materials, designs, density, and other metrics. If you’ve never used a mattress topper before, you might feel a bit lost while settling on the right material and features.
Our comprehensive buying will help you bring home an elite mattress topper in 2023 to enhance your comfort and beauty sleep.
There’s much to consider when buying a mattress topper. You must examine the padding, choose the right material, and ensure the mattress topper aligns well with your comfort preferences. Our buying guide will introduce you to all the features you need to double-check before adding a mattress topper to your cart.
Choosing the Material
Mattress toppers come in a wide array of materials, such as latex, polyester, cotton, wool, and goose feathers. We’ve compiled a list of the best materials to make a worthwhile investment.
Latex mattress toppers are expensive, but they stand unmatched in delivering comfort and cushioning support. It’s a fabulous investment to elevate your sleep station, and you can choose between natural and synthetic latex. If you struggle with pain and aching pressure points, a latex mattress topper will help align the spine and relief pain. It’s much more durable, firmer, and comfier than memory foam, and natural latex is resistant to dust mites and microbes.
A popular choice, a memory foam mattress topper is a wise investment if you have a memory foam mattress. On the other hand, if a memory foam mattress is too expensive for you, a memory foam topper can deliver the same comfort with a cheaper price tag.
We love how memory foam conforms itself to the contours of the body, providing support and relief no matter how you twist and turn while sleeping. A memory foam mattress topper is highly recommended for people struggling with muscular, back, or joint pain. What’s more, it also helps with noise reduction. “A quality, supportive mattress topper can help to evenly distribute weight and remove strain from areas that are sensitive to pressure points – particularly the shoulders, lumbar spine, hips and knees,” said Dr. Grant Radermacher, owner of Brookfield’s Ascent Chiropractic.
Homeowners who prefer natural materials and don’t mind splurging should definitely settle for a wool mattress topper. It will add a natural and cozy layer of softness to your bed, and wool offers undeniable durability that lasts a lifetime. If you or your partner are allergic to synthetic materials, this is a wise choice, and it keeps the bed bugs away.
Goose & duck feathers
If intense softness is what you desire, go for a mattress topper manufactured with goose or duck feathers. It’s intensely luxurious and will transform your bed into a cloud of softness and comfort. Its breathability and temperature regulation make it an ideal year-round investment. However, if you suffer from allergies or need firm spinal support, goose or duck feathers are not the right choice.
Cotton-polyester is a popular choice, and it opens up a world of variety to explore in budget-friendly and expensive mattress toppers. You can explore toppers with a high thread count to enjoy comfort and luxury. If you need to settle for something cheap without comprising quality, we recommend a polyester mattress topper. Cotton and polyester toppers are easy to maintain and clean, but they tend to compress and thin out very quickly.
Before you start scratching your head and imagine yourself sleeping on egg crates, know that the name is inspired by the shape of the tiny bumps on the mattress topper. These toppers are manufactured with either memory foam or even basic foam. These are a budget-friendly option, and you can carry them along on your camping trips.
Comfort, Softness & Support
Finding the perfect level of comfort and support can prove tricky, and here, you must consider your personal preferences. Do you want a mattress topper that contours to the shape of your body? Or perhaps, you want a topper that makes you feel like you’re sinking in a foamy cloud of softness?
Latex and memory foam are ideal for spinal support, firmness, and relieving pain in aching muscles and joints. Memory foam contours to the body’s shape, correcting and supporting a healthy posture. If you seek softness, you can choose naturally soft materials, such as wool, cotton, and down.
Thickness and density are crucial factors to consider. Suppose you have an aging and shriveled mattress, and you want to add more weight and plumpness to your bed. In that case, you ought to explore thicker options, such as latex and memory foam.
We firmly believe that a mattress topper is an excellent investment for your sleep quality and wellness. Suppose you can’t upgrade your mattress or bed and really want to make the sleep station more luxurious. In that case, the best mattress topper is just what you need! The extra layer of softness and support will have you feeling like you’re sleeping on a cloud of comfort and luxury.
Looking to enhance your sleep experience? The LINSY LIVING Memory Foam Mattress Topper is here to revolutionize your nights. With its gel-infused swirl design and high-density memory foam, this topper delivers unbeatable comfort and support. Say goodbye to restless nights and wake up feeling refreshed and rejuvenated.
The gel-infused swirl design keeps you cool throughout the night by dissipating heat and regulating body temperature. No more tossing and turning from discomfort caused by overheating. The high-density memory foam conforms to your body’s contours, providing exceptional comfort and support, while relieving pressure points. It’s like sleeping on a cloud!
Not only does this topper offer superior comfort, but it also breathes new life into your existing mattress. Transform your old bed into a luxurious haven without breaking the bank. Rest assured, the LINSY LIVING topper is CertiPUR-US certified, ensuring its high quality and safety for your sleep environment and making it the best overall choice.
Gel-infused swirl design for cool, comfortable nights
High-density memory foam offers exceptional support
Revitalizes your existing mattress at an affordable price
Does pain and aching pressure points keep you tossing and turning all night? A memory foam mattress topper is an excellent investment for people who struggle with pain-induced insomnia. This mattress topper comes with body-contouring memory foam with added cushioning to relieve backaches. The gel-infused material features perforations to let the airflow, giving you a cool and comfortably airy sleep station. The 3.5-pound density of the foam offers enhanced durability and longevity. It’s the perfect choice to relieve pressure so you can sleep soundly and wake up well-rested. To add the cherry on top, this mattress topper also comes with a 10-year warranty and lifetime customer service.
Memory foam is body contouring, providing pressure relief support
Gel-infused technology creates a cool sleeping environment
If you have a super-firm mattress and want to add a layer of cushiony softness that allows your body to sink into the bed, this product is perfect for you. This 3-inch memory foam mattress topper will give your sleeping environment a cushiony layer of softness. The gel-infused memory foam will relieve pressure and support airflow to keep the heat outside the sheets.
It’s the best mattress pressure for sleepers who love sinking deep into the bed. The ventilated design regulates temperature, and the breathable fabric will keep you comfortable through the night.
Gel-infused memory foam makes it soft and therapeutic
Soft and pressure-relieving formula
Ventilated design controls heat
Not suitable with a thin mattress
Not recommended for sleepers who seek firm support
Niagara Sleep Solution, a popular brand for premium bedding, presents a fantastic creation for sleepers who prefer plush comfort and overfilled thickness. This mattress topper is manufactured with a bamboo-derived fabric and overloaded with polyester fibers, designed to emulate the experience of sleeping on a cloud.
It’s a great choice if you want to add an extra layer of thickness to an aging mattress. It comes with a breathable fabric, and bamboo has the distinct quality of staying cool in the summer and cozy in the winter. We love the stretchable design that’s easy to slip on and remove, and the best part, it won’t slide off or slip when you’re enjoying your REM sleep.
Bamboo-derived fabric paired with breathable fabric makes this a great year round choice
Extra plush construction
Stretchable elastic lining that doesn’t slip or slide
Here’s the perfect pick for sleepers who want comfort and quality at an affordable price tag! Sleep Innovations is a famous and reliable brand for memory foam products, and this is one of the best mattress toppers for those shopping on a budget. Plus, this product comes with a 10-year warranty, so don’t worry about bad customer service. The 4-inch topper comes with two layers of gel-infused memory foam, delivering superior airflow and thickness.
This comfortable mattress topper will elongate and straighten your spine, relieve pressure points, and thicken up your aging mattress. The best part is, it’s hypoallergenic, making it ideal for people with sensitivities and allergies.
Gel-infused memory foam makes this ideal for pain relief
2 layers of cool foam enhance comfort
Improved airflow and breathability
Not suitable for sleepers who prefer sinking softness
This quilted mattress topper comes with an aesthetic design and a super-functional thickness that will enhance your sleep quality. It offers an extra layer of padding to plump up and revive your aging mattress. We’ve added it to our round-up because of its fine quality and ability to reduce the unwanted noise that keeps you up at night.
It’s designed with a high-quality cotton-polyester blend and extra fiberfill to create a soft, breathable, and airy sleeping environment. The stretchability and single-track elastic allow it to fit perfectly around your mattress, eliminating the possibility of slipping and sliding.
Cotton-Polyester fabric keeps the bed soft and cool
Breathable and stretchable design
Single-track elastic fits the mattress like a glove
Not suited for sleepers who prefer thickness
People Also Asked
Q: What is the best mattress topper for noise reduction?
A: If you want to tune out the tossing and turning noises of your partner, we advise investing in a memory foam mattress topper. Latex is also an excellent choice to reduce noise transmission.
Q: Which mattress topper is a good choice for all-year-round comfort?
A: Feather and wool are highly versatile materials for a mattress topper that you can enjoy throughout the year. You see, wool and down mattress toppers will keep you warm in the chill and cool in the summer.
Q: How much does the best mattress topper cost?
A: Price is a crucial consideration, but that doesn't mean you need to buy an expensive mattress topper to ensure comfort. Premium quality varieties typically range between $60 to $400, and above. Typically, durable and lasting mattress toppers come with a $100 price tag. If you're looking to buy natural materials, like wool or feathers, be prepared to splurge.
Q: Do mattress toppers help with back pain?
A: Yes! Having a mattress topper that adds and extra layer of cushion along with curving to the contour of your spine can help alleivate back pain.
Q: How long do mattress toppers last?
A: Mattress toppers can last between 3-5 years. It is best to chnage your mattress topper when it looses its cushion or if it starts to smell bad.
The Old House Journal Review Team’s product reviews and in-depth guides are here to help you restore, repair, update, and decorate your home. The content is created by The Old House Journal Review Team. The Old House Journal editorial staff is not involved. Old House Journal is reader-supported: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. All questions regarding articles or product testing can be sent to firstname.lastname@example.org
Expert Contributions By Dr. Grant Radermacher
Dr. Grant Radermacher specializes in providing safe, gentle and effective chiropractic treatment for a wide variety of conditions. With many years of chiropractic training and myofascial therapy education under his belt, Brookfield chiropractor Dr. Grant Radermacher has treated thousands of patients with conditions ranging from whiplash to scoliosis, sciatica, herniated discs, and carpal tunnel syndrome.