Whether you’ve gotten your first child or your fifth, you’ll always feel protective of your kids – it’s a natural parental instinct, after all. As such, you may take extra precautions when setting up your baby’s sleeping area.
A great item to look into is crib sheets. Yes, the sheets that your babies sleep in. They may seem unassuming at first, but certain fabrics can cause allergies, and even if they don’t, they may just feel uncomfortable for babies to sleep in. So instead of worrying over what type of crib sheet you should be getting, these cotton crib sheets will give you easy options to pick from. In this buying guide, we have put together a list of the leading crib sheets of 2023 for your baby.
Crib sheets protect both the crib itself and your baby with a soft and comfortable layer of cloth. This is all you need to know about crib sheets and what to think about when buying them.
What Are Crib Sheets Used For?
Crib sheets are layers of fabric placed over a crib mattress or material. The fabric is often made out of a material such as cotton, and the sheet will likely cover the entirety of the crib from top to bottom.
Why Are Organic Crib Sheets Important?
They keep your baby safe and comfortable
Until your baby’s old enough to sleep on a bed, they’ll need to stay somewhere they won’t just fall from in their sleep. Cribs are specifically designed to prevent sleeping kids from moving around too much, keeping them safe through the night. But that doesn’t mean they are safe from whatever’s inside the crib, and in particular, the sheets that line their cribs.
Depending on your genetics, you may be allergic to crib sheets. This is because non-organic crib sheets may contain chemicals or compounds that the skin can be allergic to. And as your baby’s still in the process of growing up, the last thing you’d want is for them to develop an allergy at such a young age.
While it isn’t guaranteed, organic cotton crib sheets help minimize the risks of your child getting skin irritations from crib sheets. They’ll be able to sleep like, well, a baby, and they won’t feel any discomfort in the process.
Cotton is a very common fabric, popular for its comfortability. Cotton sheets feel soft and fluffy to the touch, and this is perfect for babies with growing and developing skin.
They protect your mattress from your baby
While cribs can cause threats to your child’s overall health, your child can also damage your crib. In particular, if your baby makes a mess of things, it can be very difficult to clean up if the crib’s mattress isn’t protected with even a thin layer of cotton or some other material.
Just as babies are protected from exposed crib mattresses, thanks to the crib sheet, it works the other way, too. Crib sheets are what keep the mattress clean at all times, so even if the dust settles on a crib after not being used for days, you can simply remove the sheet and replace it, making it good as new. This is also helpful if your baby ever ends up vomiting in the crib or any other circumstance.
Factors in Choosing the Right Crib Sheet
How big is your baby’s crib? While there is some degree of standardization for baby cribs and their sizes, it isn’t always followed, especially if it’s from a higher-end brand or company. Expect those products to have a special, unique size instead. As such, you’ll want to figure out just how large your crib (or future crib that you have yet to buy) is, as that will dictate the size of your crib sheet.
You don’t need to always get the exact size. As long as it’s of the same size or bigger, you should be fine. If the sheet is just a little too big, you can have the sheet’s elastic lining handle the rest, and if that doesn’t work, simply tucking the excess sheet underneath can do the trick, too.
And if you’ve got a crib that’s from a popular or well-known brand, there’s a good chance that they have crib sheets designed just for that crib. The company that makes the crib will sometimes sell their own spare sheets, though this is always not the case. As always, do your research before buying the right size just so that you don’t end up with an incompatible product.
Many parents love sprucing up their baby’s room, even if the babies themselves have no idea what they’re looking at until they grow a little older. The design may not play as big of an important factor to babies as they do to you, but it’s still something worth considering. With the right design, you can add to the overall style of the room, giving it the right centerpiece to tie everything together.
How Much Do Crib Sheets Cost?
Crib sheets can range heavily in price depending on the brand, materials used, size, and so on. For crib sheets made out of organic cotton, expect to spend anywhere between $20 and $50, with a few products exceeding that amount. You can get a decent crib sheet in the $20 range, and as you go up, you’ll find better designs, larger sizes, and sometimes even extra crib sheets. At over $50, you’ll generally only be left with really high-end and expensive brands as well as deals of multiple sheets in one pack.
Highest-Rated Organic Cotton Crib Sheet Models of 2023
Soft fabrics? 100% organic cotton? Various color options? This crib sheet collection has that and more, making it our top pick on the list. It’s got over 12,000 reviews on Amazon, with a whopping 5-star rating, so it’s safe to say that it’s loved by thousands if not tens of thousands of parents. The crib sheet comes in three different sizes, including a crib-sized, a mini crib-sized, and a bassinet-sized option.
The sheets are made with premium elastic on the edges to ensure a snug fit across a variety of cribs. The many color options are also worth noting, as they give the parents a bit of designing freedom to really flesh out a particular color theme for their baby’s room. Finally, the company behind these crib sheets is climate pledge friendly, which means that they pass sustainability certifications, so you can be assured that you’re supporting a sustainable company.
Looking for something with a little more flair? Though the previous product definitely had a lot of good things to talk about, it lacked that visual appeal that could be used to entice and excite your kid. Even at a young age, kids are attracted to designs and patterns, and you can deck out their literal crib with the right crib sheets.
With relatively unisex designs for both sheets, this set of two crib sheets has what you need to fit cribs for any child. They may look a little bland in terms of color, but the stars and elephant patterns are sure to give your kid something interesting to look at. And the aspect of getting two sheets in one purchase also means that you can use one with the other in the wash, guaranteeing that you can keep the crib nice and clean all the time.
If you thought that the previous crib sheet set had interesting designs, wait till you take a look at these sheets by HonestBaby. The sheets are available in over 30 different patterns and shapes, and each one looks unique enough to stand out on its own. The designs range from plain colors to simple stripes and more elaborate markings and patterns. You’ve got a lot of sheets to choose from, and this may even pose a problem for some.
Once you’ve nailed the right sheet, however, you’re pretty much set. Though the sheet only comes in one size, they perfectly fit the cribs that they were designed for. Made out of 100% cotton, the crib sheets feel nice and soft to the touch, and they won’t harm your baby and their skin, either. It’s an overall great line of crib sheets, though you may have trouble picking the ideal one.
Plenty of designs to pick from
Ready to give as gifts
Can be difficult to choose from the variety of options
If you’re reading this list, there’s a good chance that you already have a crib at home and you just want to get another set of sheets to replace the old ones. But some of you may not even have a crib just yet, and this next product was picked just for you. The sheets themselves are great, and while we will get into them in a bit, you can actually buy a mini-crib to go along with the sheets if you already don’t have one.
Now, onto the sheets themselves. With a handful of pattern options, you aren’t starved for choice, and there are a few designs that would go well with common baby room layouts and designs. The crib sheet comes in packs of two, and if you aren’t satisfied with your product, you can always ask for a replacement or even get your money back. It’s a lifetime guarantee, too, which makes it even more impressive of a guarantee.
When designing crib sheets, many manufacturers consider the comfortability and value of the sheets, but not always the safety. This set of crib sheets made by Luvberries takes safety to a whole new level with its inclusion of what they call safety tab slots. These slots help keep the crib in place more tightly, which is perfect if you want to ensure a safe environment for your baby during their stay in the crib.
Made with a premium super-soft jersey, you will not be wanting for quality. It’s got an original heart and snowflake pattern that’s great to use any time of the year. The only real issue with this crib, however, is that it’s designed for a specific crib model – the Guava Lotus Travel Crib – so if you don’t have that particular crib at home, consider another crib sheet product instead.
Extremely soft jersey fabric
With four safety tab slots
Only suitable for one type of crib
People Also Asked
Q: Why should I get a crib sheet?
A: A crib sheet can protect your crib from your baby’s activities in the crib, and it protects the baby from irritated skin, too.
Q: When should I get a crib sheet?
A: If your old crib sheet is wearing out or you simply do not have one, it’s worth getting any crib sheet just to serve the purpose of protecting both your child and their crib mattress from one another.
Q: Is a toddler sheet the same as a crib sheet?
A: Toddler sheets and crib sheets are usually the same size, 28x52 inches.
Q: What bedding goes in a crib?
A: For your child's safety, avoid pillows, thin blankets, flat sheets, and comforters. An infant's bed only needs an encasement, pad, and a fitted sheet.
Q: Are crib sheets one size fits all?
A: No, not all crib sheets are the same size. It is important to know the exact size of your crib's mattress.
The Old House Journal Review Team’s product reviews and in-depth guides are here to help you restore, repair, update, and decorate your home. The content is created by The Old House Journal Review Team. The Old House Journal editorial staff is not involved. Old House Journal is reader-supported: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.