If you are someone who believes that pillowcases are enough to protect your pillows and keep them clean – you might want to think again.
Though pillowcases go on top of your pillows, they don’t provide enough protection to keep them safe from dust and germs, which is exactly why we need pillow protectors. A pillow protector helps seal your pillow against all sorts of unwanted substances. In short, a pillow protector goes on top of the pillow, and the pillowcase goes on top of the pillow protector.
However, with so many different types of pillow protectors in the market, it can become confusing to choose the right one for yourself. No worries! We are here to help you out. In this 2023 pillow protector buying guide, we are going to review the top pillow protectors available in the market. We have also included a buying guide for your help. Let’s get right into it.
Still not sure how to purchase the best pillow protector for yourself? This buying guide will assist you in buying the pillow protector that suits all your needs and is worth your money.
Size is one of the main factors that need to be considered before the purchase is made. Since pillow protectors are made for pillows of all shapes and sizes, you should measure your pillow and know its size so you can purchase a pillow protector accordingly. For example, a king-sized pillow protector won’t fit a queen-size pillow and vice versa.
Every type of pillow protector is made using different types of technology; hence the features of every protector also differ. The common features that need to be considered usually include pore sizes, membranes, thread counts, etc. Furthermore, some pillows are waterproof and some are not. It’s essential that you know what types of functions and features you would want your ideal pillow protector covers to have.
The comfort that a pillow protector provides usually depends on the type of material it is made from. The majority of the pillow covers are made from polyester, terry cloth, and cotton. Choose the material that suits your skin and is comfortable for you to touch, smell, and feel. Buying the wrong pillow cover material can impact your quality of sleep adversely.
Breathability and comfort go hand in hand. Breathability depends heavily on the type of material or fabric that is used to make the pillow cover. Pillow covers that are made from tightly woven fabrics seldom offer enough breathability, whereas the ones that consist of membranes are known to allow proper airflow and breathability.
Generally, breathable pillow protectors are the better and most preferred option since they keep the pillow odorless and fresh for a longer time.
Material and Durability
Pillow protectors can be made from several different types of materials, such as Terry, Cotton, Wool, Tencel Fabric, Polyester, and more. The type of material decides the durability, texture, softness, thickness, noisiness, washability, and breathability of your pillow protector. Martin Seeley, founder of Mattress Next Day, shares, “the number one thing you should look for in a pillow protector is durability. You want something that will be able to stand up to regular use and washing without falling apart.” He goes on to highlight options made of cotton or polyester.
Warranty and Sleep Trial
There are a lot of brands that now offer their customers a sleep trial before they actually purchase the product. It usually works by allowing the customer to try out the pillow protector at their home for a night or two and return the product if it doesn’t work out for them. If you’re confused about whether or not you should purchase a particular pillow protector – a sleep trial is always a great idea.
Also, some brands offer product warranties whereas some do not, so that’s another thing you should look into while purchasing the best pillow protector covers for yourself.
What Are the Different Types of Pillow Protectors?
Though the majority of pillow protectors look alike, they come with several differences depending on their type. Let’s have a look at some of the common types of pillow protectors.
Waterproof: These pillow protectors are made with a waterproof inner layer and a soft outer layer. This helps prevent the pillow protector from absorbing any type of sweat, saliva, and body oils – keeping the pillow clean and fresh for a longer time. Hence, you also need to wash your protectors every now and then. They also help expand the life of your pillow.
Hypoallergenic: These types of pillow protectors are made to protect the pillow against allergens and irritants that can be irritating for sleepers and can even result in the pillow becoming a breeding ground for germs and bacteria. Hypoallergenic pillows help keep allergens such as pollen, dust, and pet dander at bay. Though they work as a great option for everyone, they are especially recommended for patients with breathing problems such as sinusitis, asthma, nasal congestion, etc.
Temperature-Regulating: These types of pillow protectors are designed to promote breathability. They only ensure a relaxing sleep but also block out any allergens that can get trapped in the pillow. Temperature-regulating pillows are designed in such a way that they allow optimal airflow. Also, they tend to cool off the sleeper in hot climates and trap heat in cooler climates.
The right choice of pillow protector for you basically narrows down to your personal choice and preference. Overall, choosing a pillow protector for yourself shouldn’t be difficult as long as you know what type of product you are looking for. All the pillow protectors reviewed above are customers’ top picks, hence you can’t go wrong with them.
The Niagara Sleep Solution pillow protectors are made with cooling microfiber – a breathable fabric to keep allergens and respiratory irritations at bay. The material also helps keep the pillow cases soft, smooth, and comfortable, ensuring that your quality of sleep is never compromised.
The pillow protectors feature zippers with reinforced seams to prevent your pillow from slipping out of the case. Thanks to their premium quality, they can be washed multiple times without getting worn out. Though the Niagara sleep pillow protectors are made to be used for years, they still come with a lifetime guarantee against manufacturing defects to ensure nothing but the best experience for customers.
Come with a lifetime guarantee
Microfibres reduce respiratory problems and allergies
Everlasting comfort pillow protectors not only boast a premium build quality but also extended durability against wear and tear. These pillow protectors are so soft and thin that they don’t change the comfortable feel of your pillow when used. The protective layer they feature provides adequate breathability, allowing enough air to pass through the covers at night.
Moreover, the textured Terry cloth material keeps the pillow firm and adjusted in the pillowcase. The waterproof fabric protects your pillow from getting wet without being plasticky or stiff. Despite the additional waterproof layer, these pillow protectors are noiseless.
With more than 5000 five-star ratings, this pillow encasement pack of 2 is lauded by customers for its soft and breathable fabric. These Utopia protectors have been made to absorb moisture. Hence, they also work as a great option for people who live in hot and humid areas and are tired of their pillow protectors soaking wet from sweat.
These pillow protectors have been made with 100% knitted standard jerseys to not only provide a luxurious feel but also ensure proper ventilation for an interrupted and relaxing sleep. Moreover, they create no sound when being moved around on the bed and the zippers make sure that the pillow doesn’t budge while you are asleep.
Completely moisture and sweat-proof
Make no sound when being shuffled around
Breathable fabric ensures proper ventilation
They can become inflated if the zipper is not closed properly
The Moonsea waterproof pillow protector pack of 4 is a super budget-friendly option. Made from Jersey knit fabric, these pillow protectors are certified standard 100 by OEKO-TEX, meaning they are tested and proven to be safe-for-use and pose no harm to human health -making them a safe option for people of all ages.
The waterproof material makes them a great option for use around infants as well, eliminating the need to flip the pillow over frequently even in hot climates. Other than this, the pillow protectors are skin-friendly, so you don’t need to worry about waking up with breakouts or temporary skin wrinkling.
Come with a money-back guarantee
High-quality and 100% waterproof material
Soft and skin-friendly
Not the best option for the ones that don’t like warm pillow protectors
The AllerEase Ultimate pillow covers are made with 88% Polyester and12% Nylon to offer reliable protection against allergens. The antimicrobial finish fights off odor and sweat to ensure a clean and healthy night’s sleep. Furthermore, they are protected with durable zippers that keep out pet dander, dust mites, and other bed bugs away from your pillows.
Since these have been made keeping temperature balancing in mind, they release heat when the climate is hot and retain heat when you are feeling cold. Hence, these pillow protectors not only protect you against all sorts of contaminants but also provide you maximum comfort to allow you to sleep peacefully at night.c
Machine-wash friendly, easy to care for
Offer protection against allergens and contaminants
The Guardmax pillow protectors are a great option for you if you are looking for pillowcases that are 100% waterproof. The dual-layer design helps keep out sweat, moisture, liquid, and saliva from seeping into the pillow. Since water can’t seep through, neither can air. Also, the covers are made from polyurethane and polyester, so you can rest assured that you will be getting plenty of comfortable and relaxing night sleep.
Other than this, you don’t need to worry about any cracking or crackling noises that are common for other waterproof cases. These pillow protectors can be machine washed easily and come with a 100% satisfaction guarantee.
Last but not the least, the safeRest premium hypoallergenic pillow protector comes with hypoallergenic properties and is well-known for being durable. The strong zipper keeps the pillow safe from dust mites, bed bugs, and germ build-up, making it a great option for people with asthma and other breathing problems.
The surface of the pillow cover has been made with soft cotton terry back coated to keep it cool and noiseless. The polyurethane membrane it features is Vinyl, phthalates, and PVC-free so your pillow remains fresh and breathable at all times. Furthermore, the product comes with a 1- year warranty against manufacturer defects and is machine-washable.
Noiseless and breathable
Come with a 10-year warranty
Micro-zipper technology for protection against allergens
Feels a bit flat
People Also Asked
Q: Do you need to wash pillow protectors?
A: Yes, pillow protectors should be washed if you want to keep them clean and fresh. However, how often you should wash them depends on the type of pillow protector you are using. Waterproof and hypoallergenic pillow protectors don’t need to be washed very frequently. It is usually recommended that you wash your pillowcases along with your sheets.
Q: How long do pillow protectors last?
A: The best pillow protectors usually last for around 2-3 years. Since pillow protectors absorb sweat, dirt, allergens, body oils, and dead skin cells, it is recommended that you replace your pillow cover every two years and wash it every six months. To extend the life span of the pillow itself, you can also use a protective case between the pillow protectors and the pillow.
Q: Are waterproof pillow protectors good?
A: Waterproof pillows are a great option since they stop all sorts of liquids from seeping into the pillowcase. This helps your pillow from getting stained and discolored. It also keeps your pillow odorless and clean.
Q: What is the purpose of a pillow protector?
A: Pillow protectors protect you pillow from stains, bacteria, makeup, spills, etc. They act as an additional barrier from your skin to your pillow.
Q: What is the difference between a pillowcase and a pillow protector?
A: Pillow protectors act as a barrier between your pillow case and pillow. The pillow protect will protect your pillow from stain, spills, and other accidents that can damage your pillow.
The Old House Journal Review Team’s product reviews and in-depth guides are here to help you restore, repair, update, and decorate your home. The content is created by The Old House Journal Review Team. The Old House Journal editorial staff is not involved. Old House Journal is reader-supported: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. All questions regarding articles or product testing can be sent to firstname.lastname@example.org
Expert Contributions By Martin Seeley
Martin Seeley is a startup enthusiast, entrepreneur, sleep expert,
investor, CEO, and Founder of Mattress Next Day. They believe that good sleep is the key to a happy life, which is why we’ve partnered with some of the leading manufacturers in the UK.