logo
logo
  • Home
  • Products & Services
  • How-To
  • House Tours
  • Gardens & Exteriors
  • Kitchens & Baths
  • Interiors & Decors
  • Magazines
  • Buying Guides
    • Attic
    • Basement
    • Bed & Bath
    • Bedroom
    • Cleaning
    • Decks & Patios
    • Dining Room
    • Exterior Design
    • Garage
    • Home Office
    • Kitchen & Dining
    • Outdoor & Garden
    • Living Room
    • Smart Home
    • Home Improvement
    • Utilities
  • Reviews
  • Bed & Bath
Last updated: 16 Mar 2023
We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products-learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

Make Your Me-Time Homely With The Best Toilet Seats

author-image
By Old House Journal Review Team
Published 6:44 am

Have you ever sat on a commode with a cracked toilet seat that ended up pinching your skin? Or have you ever felt uncomfortable due to the wobbling of your commode lid? The irksome feeling that arises because of it ruins your whole day. Nature’s call is one of the consistent activities, and you cannot ruin it because of the defaulted commode. That is why we have reviewed the best toilet seats in 2023 for you to help you live your life to the fullest. 

A good toilet seat will make sure to provide you with the ultimate level of comfort and peace. Because of it, you can enjoy a serene morning and have a restful sleep. 

The Best Toilet Seat You Can Buy In 2023

1

Bemis Toilet Seat

– Best Overall
img
Buy on Amazon
Check Price On Walmart

The BEMIS 1500EC 390 toilet seat is known for its comfortable and smooth feel that takes you to a whole new world. Composed of enameled wood, this commode seat is not only eco-friendly but is also remarkable in turning your nature’s call into a radiant experience. Moreover, there are plastic hinges attached to it that are extremely easy to lock and unlock with a single twist. 

The bolts and nuts that are used to keep the seat in place do not get corroded overtime. They are 100% rust-free and play no role in destroying the look of your precious toilet. The unmatched qualities and durability of the BEMIS toilet seats makes it an excellent choice for residential as well as commercial areas.

Pros
  • Easily removable for replacement 
  • Get conveniently cleaned up with soap and water 
  • Goes well with any bathroom decor
Cons
  • Installing the seat could be difficult for some people 
2

Mayfair Toilet Seat

– Runner Up
img
Buy on Amazon

Mayfair 843 toilet seat is like a knight in shining armour that has a knack for helping you out in your two-time situation. You can depend on this beauty without worrying about the hygiene issues as it keeps the urine drippings or other unhygienic substances away from where you sit. 

Plus, you won’t have to worry about unnecessary cracking or chipping of the seat as the wood that is used in its construction is highly durable. Hence, gone are the days of pinched skin and unnecessary trouble. The high-gloss finishing touch and flawless fitting on round balls make it an exceptional product.

Pros
  • Allows convenient installation from the top 
  • Prevents slamming 
  • Easy to clean
Cons
  • Using strong chemicals to clean the seat might ruin the enamel 
3

Kohler Toilet Seat

– Honorable Mention
img
Buy on Amazon

Kohler toilet seat is specifically designed to turn your mundane morning into an amazing start with the help of its lightweight and convenient design. Once you make it a part of your toilet, you won’t have to think about changing it for a long period because of the sturdy plastic construction. Also, the slow closing mechanism keeps the lid from slamming and making unwanted noises.

The incorporation of grip-tight bumpers provides high stability and prevents the seat from shifting its position. In addition to all these features, you can also clean up your toilet without leaving out any corners, thanks to the easy removal techniques of the lid. 

Pros
  • It is very comfortable to sit on 
  • It is chip-resistant and scratch-resistant  
  • The design is quite stylish 
Cons
  • Bulky people might not find the seat comfortable 
4

WSSROGY Toilet Seat

– Also Consider
img
Buy on Amazon

Have you ever looked at your toilet and fell in love with it? Well, you will, if you attach a WSSROGY toilet seat. This commode lid gives your bathroom bowl a whole new makeover that adds a hundred points to the overall look of your washroom. Plus, there will be no more headaches because of the slamming sounds as the slow-closing mechanism of the seat prohibits it from doing so. 

This lid is made of polypropylene plastic that doesn’t get scratched or cracked. In short, the product is reliable to use for a long time. The ergonomic curved design creates relaxing vibes and provides you with a comfortable space to sit on and release your worries.

Pros
  • It comes with two sets of installation accessories for your convenience 
  • Easy to clean 
  • No slamming sounds
Cons
  • This toilet seat is not adjustable
5

DELTA FAUCET Toilet Seat

img
Buy on Amazon

DELTA FAUCET toilet seat provides a heavenly experience due to its well-built design and non-stick feature. The non-slip bumpers make sure to provide you with the best service that does not shake the world beneath you. Also, the measurements of this gem are ideal and easily fit on almost all types of standard sized elongated toilets.

The installation process is pretty straightforward and doesn’t utilize much time. Once installed properly, this seat would be secure to use without loosening. Along with its features, the appearance was also the priority of its manufacturers. That’s the reason it brings charm to your washroom when you install it on your commode.

Pros
  • Can stand the test of time
  • Super comfortable to sit on 
  • Perfect for bearing the weight of bulky people
Cons
  • This seat is not suitable for commercial use

Buying Guide for the Best Toilet Seats

It’s time to tweak your commode with the best toilet seats in 2021 to ensure maximum comfort and ease. 

What To Take Into Consideration While Choosing the Best Toilet Seats?

As there are a variety of toilet seats roaming around, it is tough to make a wise and quick choice. Here are some of the tips that will help you choose the best toilet seat in no time.

No wiggling

Before choosing the best toilet seat, you need to take proper measurements of the toilet bowl. A commode lid that fits properly on your toilet will not wiggle or vibrate when you sit on it. In other words, you need to choose the correct shape of the toilet seat that will be ideal for your commode. 

Material used

The material used in the making of the toilet seat plays a significant role when it comes to durability and comfort level. For instance, if you live in a colder region, choosing a wood toilet seat is better than plastic. It is because plastic seats tend to get colder in winters than wood lids, and you definitely do not want that.

Simple installation process

In addition to the shape and material, get your hands on the comparatively easy-to-install lid. You wouldn’t want to hit your head on the wall due to the hassle of so many bolts and screws. That’s why we’d recommend you go for the one that does not have a rigorous or lengthy installation process. 

Noise factor

The noise factor is yet another point that you shouldn’t forget. If you are easily irritated by loud sounds, then make sure to buy a toilet seat with a soft-close feature or one that is padded. On the other hand, if noise is not a problem for you, you can choose other ones as well.

What Types of Toilet Seats Are up for Grabs?

During the past few years, toilets have evolved to a great extent. With the evolution of various urinals and commodes, toilet seats have undergone a reasonable change as well. Although multiple designs are available on the market now, all of them are the subcategories of three main types of toilet seats.

Round toilet seats

These are the most common and widely used toilet seats of all. They are used mainly in home toilets and don’t cost much. Roughly the size of 16.5 inches, round toilet lids take less space and are readily available at sanitary stores. 

Elongated or oval toilet seats

Elongated toilet seats are primarily used in commercial spaces, restaurants, or offices. They come in 18-inch size and ensure the comfort level of their users. As compared to the round toilet seats, they are a bit more expensive. 

U-shaped or open toilet seats

This type of commode lid is primarily used in public toilets, where many people tend to use the same commodes. The U-shape keeps the genitals of a man away from the toilet seat and protects the toilet from urine drips. 

Which Materials Are Used in the Making of Toilet Seats?

When it comes to the materials used in the composition of toilet lids, there are no limits. Many materials can be used in the construction of these bowls. These are: 

  • Plastic: One of the most common materials used in making toilet seats is plastic. It is not so strong as compared to the rest of the materials and turns yellow over time.
  • Duroplast: It is basically a polymer blend and provides strong resistance to UV rays and toilet cleaners.
  • Thermoplastic: This type of plastic is the hardest one as the molding injection is used to make it. As compared to the regular plastic seats, these are relatively shiny and sturdy. 
  • Synthetic Resin: When a liquid or powdered resin is compressed with the help of a hardening agent, synthetic resin is formed. This material provides a scratch-proof and smooth finishing to the toilet seats.
  • Wood: Several types of wood, including oak and bamboo, are used in the composition of commode seats. They are eco-friendly and provide an aesthetic touch to your toilet. 
  • Stainless steel: Toilet seats composed of this material is considered heavy-duty and are quite expensive compared to the rest of the materials.

What Special Features Are Incorporated in the Best Toilet Seats?

Toilet seats have become an art in the modern world, as various new functions have been added to uplift the feel of your washroom. 

Soft close toilet seats

Typically, used toilet seats have a knack for making a loud sound when you drop them. This issue has been resolved with the invention of soft-close toilet seats. These toilet lids of covers do not close abruptly when you are done with your service. Instead of dropping instantly, the seat falls smoothly and slowly, keeping it from making any unnecessary noise. 

Quick release toilet seats

When you are cleaning your toilet, you may find it hard to reach certain corners because of the permanent attachment of the toilet cover. With the help of quick-release toilet seats, you can conveniently take off the center and the lid and clean your toilet thoroughly. After completing the task, simply put them back. 

Lighted toilet seats

This feature allows your toilet seat to light up in the dark. Suppose you wake up in the middle of the night to pee, but you do not want to disturb others by turning the light on. The lighted toilet seat will enable you to find the commode even in the dark because it will be glowing, just for you!

Final Words

Toilet seats have the tendency to make or break your day; that’s why you must pay close attention to them. There are multiple types of commode lids, including rounded, elongated, and U-shaped toilet seats. In addition to the main types, you can choose the type of material you want, ranging from plastic to stainless steel. 

As there are so many options, keep in mind the essential points like shape, material, and installation process of the toilet seat to make the best choice. Moreover, you can also get your hands to toilet lids with features like soft-closure, quick release, and lighted backs. Whatever you decide, our list of the best toilet seats in 2021 has everything you have been looking for.

Toilet Seat FAQ

Q: Can I replace a round toilet seat with an elongated one?

A: You can replace a round toilet seat with an elongated one, but it may not fit properly and end up wiggling when you sit on it. 

Q: Do all toilet seats fit the same?

A: Standard toilet seats fit on standard commodes. However, if your commode has varying dimensions, you will need a toilet seat of different sizes as well.

Q: What causes yellow stains on toilet seats?

A: Hard water that is typically used at homes causes yellow stains on toilet seats.

Bathroom Hardware
author-image
By Old House Journal Review Team
The Old House Journal Review Team’s product reviews and in-depth guides are here to help you restore, repair, update, and decorate your home. The content is created by The Old House Journal Review Team. The Old House Journal editorial staff is not involved. Old House Journal is reader-supported: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Related Reviews
img
Bring Luxury to Your Bathroom Using the Best Bidet
img
Make Your Showers Relaxing and Functional With the Best Shower Bench
img
The Best Adjustable Shower Arms To Make Your Bath Time More Relaxing And Soothing
  • Subscribe to Magazine
  • Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Get Your Company Listed
  • Digital Editions
  • Subscription Services
  • Renew Subscription
  • Give a Gift
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising
  • Sister Sites
  • Traditional Building
  • Period Homes
  • Arts & Crafts Homes
  • Log Home Living
  • Woodsmith
  • Timber Home Living
  • Popular Woodworking
  • Horticulture
  • Cuisine at Home
  • Writers Digest
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
© 2023 Old House Journal