Restoring a Vintage Door in a 1920s Tudor House

The arch-top entry door, a signature piece of the century-old Tudor Revival house, was in bad shape. A local carpenter made expert repairs.

When we first visited the house, four years ago, we noticed signs of damage to the front door. Surrounded by stone quoins, the door has a fixed, leaded-glass window that depicts a hand-painted crest of the family who built it, in the mid-1920s. The door is faced in oak on the exterior with massive decorative strap hinges and coordinating entry hardware. Inside, the door is paneled in walnut. 

Once endangered and now repaired, the graceful arch-top door is ready for the next hundred years. INSET: Before repairs, the author turned the improvised covering over the door into a Halloween decoration.

The bottom rail was suspect. Even from a distance, you could see that the door had previously been repaired, and not well. The extent of the damage was not immediately obvious, though. We moved in and put the repair on our to-do list.

Other projects took precedence (including a flood in the basement that necessitated an extensive drainage overhaul), so we didn’t get to the door right away. This is our main entrance, used daily, so it wasn’t long before we noticed that the varnish was delaminating and peeling along the lower third of the door, a sign of water intrusion.

The half-round copper gutter above the door was not well adjusted and not snugged to the slate. Rainwater had been running between the roof and the gutter, creating a thin wall of water that hit the limestone door sill below. The water bounced up onto the door, then percolated into the wood where the varnish was peeling away. The old, dry end-grain of the vertical panels above the bottom rail were soaking up water, too, creating significant, almost hidden wood rot.

We began by fixing the gutter, to eliminate water leakage. Then we removed the strap hinge from the lower part of the door and sent the bottom rail to a local wood shop recommended to us by a contractor familiar with the house. The bottom rail was too far gone to save, and our carpenter, Ricardo Martinez, also proposed replacing the four vertical inset panels, which were similarly damaged.

 In 2021, the finish on the bottom of the door showed signs of swelling and delamination.
By fall, the damage was so pronounced the owner had protected it with plastic wrap.
Once the bottom rail was removed, the extent of interior rot was obvious.

Martinez and his team carefully matched the wood on both sides of the door using the same species and similar grain: oak on the exterior, walnut veneer on the interior. To add strength and structural stability, the oak and walnut facings were sandwiched together over a dimensionally stable core, similar to the ones used in modern, high-end door construction. 

Repairs to the door included replacing the bottom rail and all four vertical panels with wood carefully matched to the original.

After the repairs were made, Ricardo and his helpers carefully test-hung the door to make sure it fit properly. Then they finish-sanded and stained the wood to match the existing stain on the older parts of the door. 

Ricardo Martinez and Eric Gutierrez test-fit the door before final sanding and stain matching.

Now, it’s almost impossible to tell that the door was ever endangered. A custom-built, protective storm door is on the way, too—ensuring that the restored door will be protected for years to come.

The newly-restored door.


Martinez Carpentry and Masonry, Winston-Salem, NC
(336) 362-4563

Arched doors (new):
Vintage Doors
Arch- & round-top panel doors, with mouldings & glazing, in many configurations incl. Double, Gothic, with sidelights, in 12 wood species

Tags: OHJ December 2022

Product of the Week

© Copyright 2023 Home Group, a division of Active Interest Media. All Rights Reserved.

2143 Grand Avenue, Des Moines, IA 50312